Thursday, February 12, 2015

Blog #3: As Jazz Grows, So Does Racism

Jazz was created, nurtured, and performed by the African Americans, and the whites paid for it, by building clubs and paying jazz musicians. The whites and blacks had always had a partially tense but generally congenial, but when the swing era came around the tension rose between the two groups. This tension was generally created by the simple fact that jazz was now classy. One no longer had to mingle with the…working class. The family could now enjoy Jazz without stepping onto the sweaty dance floors of less-than-legal night clubs. People could now enjoy jazz on the radio, something that even the poor American sleeping in the gutter might have a chance to listen. And with this flowering of popularity there came a heightened interest in bands. People everywhere wanted to hear bands live in there town. This immediately created problems with the Jim Crow laws and just racism in general. “because there were only about a half-dozen hotels for African-Americans in the southern states, musicians were often forced to canvas black neighborhoods for places to sleep, after arriving late at night”(Swing Changes, 126). Blacks faced incredible odds like this often having to travel a "distance of anywhere from several hundred to a thousand miles from gig to gig"(Gioia,148).
Black bands had a much harder time receiving gigs and getting recognition. Benny Goodman, the “King of Jazz” was easily out played by Chick Webb, but Benny Goodman was the one to go on to Carnegie Hall and Chick Webb unceremoniously stayed in Harlem playing for largely black audience. Most of the Racism before this was slightly ignored or not too bad. “The conditions and prospects faced by African American and white bands had never been equivalent, and as swing became profitable business the disparity between the two groups increased”(Swing Changes, 122). White musicians had always had the better pay and the better night clubs, but they were still all nightclubs and the pay was still pretty much similar, but when the Swing era came around, there was a much bigger difference between the opportunities presented to the musicians, the Savoy and Carnegie Hall were two totally different levels of fame. When the producers are white and the audiences are white, a musician with a paler completion is much easier to market. “White imitations of the…[black bands]…proved more acceptable to a mass audience”(Swing Changes, 122).
The other big race problem that came up in the popularity of Jazz was the critics who’s jobs were created by a type of music that hadn’t existed on this scale before, who were mostly, if not completely, white. These new critics who were deciding who was good and who would disappear into obscurity, created a thin line for blacks to walk on. “Many of the writers who criticized or reviewed jazz sought to define a political meaning to the music”(Swing Changes, 53).This forced the black musicians to make music that satisfied this search for meaning but of course they also had to appear non-threatening to the white audiences, while at the same time had to be sympathetic to black causes and not sell themselves out completely. And even if they followed the narrow guidelines produced by critics like Hammond, they still received inferior pay, and inferior reputation to the white bands. The blacks truly couldn’t win in this era.

This all just leads up to the answer about why Racism is more explicitly mentioned in writings of the swing era. It’s because more problems happened. These problems were more widespread and far more obvious. When black musicians, 70 years after the end of slavery, were put out of their own creation the anti-racist fervor began to grow.

Commented on Steenalisa Tilcock . 

Thursday, February 5, 2015

Blog 2: How New York Changed Jazz

The 1920s marked a big change from the small city life of early Jazz which found its home in the dirty crevasses of brothels and bars of Storyville. The new Jazz lived in a much different place; one with glamorous chandeliers and lit up signs. The new Jazz had moved to the big city, and it was enjoying it immensely. Jazz moved to the bright lights of New York and Chicago, where the big cities gave it a place (and the money) for it to grow past its adolescence. The city of New York, however, was where it truly triumphed into something quite special. New York had all the bells and whistles of Chicago, with the big clubs owned by rich gang lords, but offered it on a much bigger scale where clubs still existed, but on top of that the Jazz musicians had access to the massive stage of Broadway, where small Jazz acts could be presented to massive audiences and was fueled by the Harlem Renaissance.

While Chicago Jazz was mostly derived from New Orleans transplants, New York Jazz set the stage by itself: first with ragtime, which developed into the stride piano, which eventually morphed into Jazz. In addition, Jazz had its roots among the people. Unlike Chicago, where Jazz went straight to the speakeasy, New York Jazz started in the homes of the poor man in Harlem where rent parties drew people together to hear the new music forming on the streets. “Rent parties were the ‘special passion of the community'”(Gioia, 90) Eventually white businessmen brought these people out of Harlem and onto Broadway, but it had to grow from the bottom up.

New York Jazz also had all the great bandleaders who helped Jazz become what it is known today. James P. Johnson, Fatts Waller, Fletcher Henderson, and Duke Ellington, are just a few of the famous band leaders who brought Jazz to where it is today. While there were several good musicians in Chicago, they were mostly just from New Orleans only spent passing hours in Chicago before moving on to New York. “The association of the so called Chicago style of music with its leading figure, Bix Beiderbecke, is also puzzling. Bix played little in Chicago—if anything, his residencies in New York stand out as the decisive interludes in his musical career.” (Gioia, 71). Bix Beiderbecke and Louis Armstrong, two of the most popular Jazz musicians in Chicago, spent a great deal of their careers in the much nicer clubs of New York, where they molded and changed Jazz.


Fletcher Henderson put this final piece of success for Jazz in New York when he brought Armstrong over from Chicago. “More than any other event, Henderson’s hiring of Louis Armstrong in 1924 served as a catalyst in accelerating the band’s evolution”(Gioia, 105) Henderson allowed the ragtime dance music of New York and the Jazz of New Orleans (via a brief stay in Chicago) to meld together and make something unique. Louis Armstrong can be seen as a personification of Jazz and his route through life would be the route Jazz took to becoming the soul of American music. Born as a country bumpkin in New Orleans, Jazz moved up to Chicago where it became second trumpet to an older style, and then moved to New York where it truly became the center stage and directed the rest of music into its folds. New York Jazz had its own feel that would eventually come to feel like swing. Stride Piano and the European march feel pushed together with the sprinkling of southern blues would forever give New York Jazz different feel than New Orleans Jazz (and its younger brother Chicago Jazz) it was a Jazz that would become modern Jazz. It would become a precursor for swing which would captivate the country for years to come.

Commented on